[PATCH v2 4/4] phy: rockchip-typec: Don't set the aux voltage swing to 400 mV

[Douglas Anderson]

On rk3399-gru-kevin there are some cases where we're seeing AUX CH
failures when trying to do DisplayPort over type C.  Problems are
intermittent and don't reproduce all the time.  Problems are often
bursty and failures persist for several seconds before going away.
The failure case I focused on is:
* A particular type C to HDMI adapter.
* One orientation (flip mode) of that adapter.
* Easier to see failures when something is plugged into the _other
  type C port at the same time.
* Problems reproduce on both type C ports (left and right side).

Ironically problems also stop reproducing when I solder wires onto the
AUX CH signals on a port (even if no scope is connected to the
signals).  In this case, problems only stop reproducing on the port
with the wires connected.

>From the above it appears that something about the signaling on the
aux channel is marginal and any slight differences can bring us over
the edge to failure.

It turns out that we can fix our problems by just increasing the
voltage swing of the AUX CH, giving us a bunch of extra margin.  In DP
up to version 1.2 the voltage swing on the aux channel was specced as
.29 V to 1.38 V.  In DP version 1.3 the aux channel voltage was
tightened to be between .29 V and .40 V, but it clarifies that it
really only needs the lower voltage when operating at the highest
speed (HBR3 mode).  So right now we are trying to use a voltage that
technically should be valid for all versions of the spec (including
version 1.3 when transmitting at HBR3).  That would be great to do if
it worked reliably.  ...but it doesn't seem to.

It turns out that if you continue to read through the DP part of the
rk3399 TRM and other parts of the type C PHY spec you'll find out that
while the rk3399 does support DP 1.3, it doesn't support HBR3.  The
docs specifically say "RBR, HBR and HBR2 data rates only".  Thus there
is actually no requirement to support an AUX CH swing of .4 V.

Even if there is no actual requirement to support the tighter voltage
swing, one could possibly argue that we should support it anyway.  The
DP spec clarifies that the lower voltage on the AUX CH will reduce
cross talk in some cases and that seems like it could be beneficial
even at the lower bit rates.  At the moment, though, we are seeing
problems with the AUX CH and not on the other lines.  Also, checking
another known working and similar laptop shows that the other laptop
runs the AUX channel at a higher voltage.

Other notes:
* Looking at measurements done on the AUX CH we weren't actually
  compliant with the DP 1.3 spec anyway.  AUX CH peek-to-peek voltage
  was measured on rk3399-gru-kevin as .466 V which is > .4 V.
* With this new patch the AUX channel isn't actually 1.0 V, but it has
  been confirmed that the signal is better and has more margin.  Eye
  diagram passes.
* If someone were truly an expert in the Type C PHY and in DisplayPort
  signaling they might be able to make things work and keep the
  voltage at < .4 V.  The Type C PHY seems to have a plethora of
  tuning knobs that could almost certainly improve the signal
  integrity.  Some of these things (like enabling tx_fcm_full_margin)
  even seem to fix my problems.  However, lacking expertise I can't
  say whether this is a better or worse solution.  Tightening signals
  to give cleaner waveforms can often have adverse affects, like
  increasing EMI or adding noise to other signals.  I'd rather not
  tune things like this without a healthy application of expertise
  that I don't have.

Signed-off-by: Douglas Anderson <dianders at chromium.org>
---

Changes in v2:
- Voltage swing patch new for v2.

 drivers/phy/rockchip/phy-rockchip-typec.c | 4 ++--
 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)

diff --git a/drivers/phy/rockchip/phy-rockchip-typec.c b/drivers/phy/rockchip/phy-rockchip-typec.c
index a1f961844efe..a96635447d48 100644
--- a/drivers/phy/rockchip/phy-rockchip-typec.c
+++ b/drivers/phy/rockchip/phy-rockchip-typec.c
@@ -669,8 +669,8 @@ static void tcphy_dp_aux_calibration(struct rockchip_typec_phy *tcphy)
 	 */
 	writel(0, tcphy->base + TX_ANA_CTRL_REG_4);
 
-	/* Set voltage swing to 400 mV peak to peak (differential) */
-	writel(LOW_POWER_SWING_EN, tcphy->base + TXDA_COEFF_CALC_CTRL);
+	/* Don't set voltage swing to 400 mV peak to peak (differential) */
+	writel(0, tcphy->base + TXDA_COEFF_CALC_CTRL);
 
 	/* Init TXDA_CYA_AUXDA_CYA for unknown magic reasons */
 	writel(0, tcphy->base + TXDA_CYA_AUXDA_CYA);
-- 
2.14.1.690.gbb1197296e-goog