JFFS2 deadlock

[Thomas.Betker at rohde-schwarz.com]

Hello David:

> > Please could you try what's in the tree at
> > http://git.infradead.org/users/dwmw2/jffs2-fixes.git

> Your patch looks much simpler, and I will definitely test it. It may
> take a few days, though, as I have to unearth the test scripts, and 
> find a time slot for testing.

Here is what I did (sorry for the wait, things were piling up):

1) Removed Deng Chao's patch from my kernel, added your patch "jffs2: Fix 
page lock / f->sem deadlock". I am still on linux-3.14, but jffs2 hasn't 
changed much since then, so this shouldn't make a difference. Added a 
printk() before mutex_unlock(&f->sem) to check if the prospective page was 
locked, i.e. if the deadlock situation actually occurs.

2) On my target system, started wangzaiwei's test (with some fixes), plus 
a loop copying a large file over and over (to get GC rolling, which 
increases the chance of a deadlock).

3) After 24 hours, the system was still alive, and the printk() had been 
hit 32 times.

So yes, I am confident that your patch avoids the deadlock, and if that's 
good enough for you, please add my Tested-by:. However, I am going to run 
some more stress tests here just to check that there weren't any 
unexpected side effects. (Don't get me wrong -- I am sure the patch is 
fine, but for me it's a case of "once bitten, twice shy" ...)

Best regards,
Thomas Betker