[wireless-regdb] Question about 5.8 GHz in E.U.
mathieu.peyrega at gmail.com
Thu Sep 7 07:03:19 PDT 2017
unfortunately, my wifi skills are not (yet ?) allowing me to track
further than what the "iw reg get" command tells me (confirmed by some
off the shelf Wifi analyzer sofwares).
Do you have pointers/tutorial to help me doing that ?
Further reading your answer, my guess is that DJI has complied to UNII-3
choice. At least on their website Spark spec page, they clearly give the
good max power figures and make the difference between FCC and EU areas.
This leads to my concern about why not adding the matching rules in the
DB for EU countries that have transposed it into their laws.
Is this regulatory DB supposed to strictly reflect the current state of
local regulations or doe it also endorse a higher level of
"responsability" in order to prevent issues with non complient devices
as I understand your fears ?
Le 07/09/2017 à 15:44, Ryan Mounce a écrit :
> You can see the 'FR' Country Code, can you see the full 802.11d
> Country Information IE that is broadcast by the DJI drone?
> I can see how this situation has come about. In much of the world
> including China (DJI) and the USA (DJI's largest international market)
> the 'UNII-3' equivalent range is a simple default choice with high
> power and outdoor use permitted, with no DFS to worry about.
> Europe is not so simple. In roughly descending order of device compatibility.
> 2.4GHz has power restrictions compared to USA/China, and is polluted
> in every country.
> UNII-1 is indoor only and should require the user to confirm they are
> indoors (for a device like a drone that is likely to be used outdoors,
> unlike a home WiFi AP)
> UNII-2 adds DFS and TPC restrictions to UNII-1, quite restrictive.
> UNII-2E is fairly quiet and allows more generous power, however DFS is
> still a consideration and a portable device like a drone would have to
> scan for at least 60 seconds before broadcasting in this band.
> UNII-3 has the strictest power restrictions of all, and thus the most
> limited range.
> So it seems that DJI have simply ignored this altogether, and are
> broadcasting in a poorly supported frequency band in Europe with
> either a very weak short range signal or a very strong signal in
> violation of regulations. Either way, this is very much their problem
> (and unfortunately also their customers').
tel : +33 (0)6 87 30 83 59
More information about the wireless-regdb