[PATCH v1] net: phy: fix motorcomm module automatic loading

[Heiner Kallweit]

On 30.04.2022 18:31, Peter Geis wrote:
> On Sat, Apr 30, 2022 at 11:52 AM Andrew Lunn <andrew at lunn.ch> wrote:
>>
>>> Good Morning,
>>>
>>> After testing various configurations I found what is actually
>>> happening here. When libphy is built in but the phy drivers are
>>> modules and not available in the initrd, the generic phy driver binds
>>> here. This allows the phy to come up but it is not functional.
>>
>> What MAC are you using?
> 
> Specifically Motorcomm, but I've discovered it can happen with any of
> the phy drivers with the right kconfig.
> 
>>
>> Why is you interface being brought up by the initramfs? Are you using
>> NFS root from within the initramfs?
> 
> This was discovered with embedded programming. It's common to have a
> small initramfs, or forgo an initramfs altogether. Another cause is a
> mismatch in kernel config where phylib is built in because of a
> dependency, but the rest of the phy drivers are modular.
> The key is:
> - phylib is built in
> - ethernet driver is built in
> - the phy driver is a module
> - modules aren't available at probe time (for any reason).
> 
> In this case phylib assumes there is no driver, when the vast majority
> of phys now have device specific drivers.It seems this is an unsafe
> assumption as this means there is now an implicit dependency of the
> device specific phy drivers and phylib. It just so happens to work
> simply because both broadcom and realtek, some of the more common
> phys, have explicit dependencies elsewhere that cause them to be built
> in as well.
> 
Because you mention the realtek phy driver:
Users reported similar issues like you if r8169 MAC driver is built-in
(or r8169 module is in initramfs) but realtek phy driver is not.
There's no direct code dependency between r8169 and realtek phy driver,
therefore initramfs-creating tools sometimes missed to automatically
include the phy driver in initramfs. To mitigate this r8169 has the following:
MODULE_SOFTDEP("pre: realtek");
This isn't strictly needed but some initramfs-creating tools consider
such soft dependencies when checking what should be included in initramfs.
If some other MAC is used with a Realtek PHY, then you may still see the
described issue.
As Andrew wrote: Eventually it's a userspace responsibility to ensure that
all needed modules are included in initramfs.

>>>> What normally happens is that the kernel loads, maybe with the MAC
>> driver and phylib loading, as part of the initramfs. The other modules
>> in the initramfs allow the root filesystem to be found, mounted, and
>> pivoted into it. The MAC driver is then brought up by the initscripts,
>> which causes phylib to request the needed PHY driver modules, it loads
>> and all is good.
>>
>> If you are using NFS root, then the load of the PHY driver happens
>> earlier, inside the initramfs. If this is you situation, maybe the
>> correct fix is to teach the initramfs tools to include the PHY drivers
>> when NFS root is being used?
>>
>>      Andrew