[PATCH v3 2/9] nvme-fabrics: allow to queue requests for live queues

Sagi Grimberg sagi at grimberg.me
Fri Aug 21 15:44:56 EDT 2020


>> I still dislike any random ioctls coming in while we're still initializing
>> the controller.
> 
> Agreed.
> 
>>    Looking at the flow - I wouldn't want them to be allowed
>> until after nvme_init_identify() is complete. Especially if the ioctls are
>> doing subsystem or controller dumping or using commands that should be
>> capped by values set by nvme_queue_limits().   But, if we're going to
>> allow nvme_init_identify the admin_q needs to be unquiesced.
>>
>> So I'm still voting for the admin queue exception.
> 
> And I really don't like the admin queue special case.  What is the
> advantage of letting user space passthrough I/O commands in at this
> point in time?

We need to pass in normal I/O commands for sure in order to have a
robust reset and error recovery (what in general the patchset
addresses). What is the difference between FS I/O commands and
passthru I/O commands? In fact, user passthru I/O commands will never
execute before nvme_init_identify() because we always start
the I/O queues after that.

Let's look at pci, do we have the same enforcement for passthru
commands? What's special about fabrics that we need to deny
these commands from going through?



More information about the Linux-nvme mailing list