[PATCH 03/18] mtd: dataflash: Export OF module alias information

[Javier Martinez Canillas]

Hello Brian,

On 08/20/2015 11:54 PM, Brian Norris wrote:
> On Thu, Aug 20, 2015 at 09:07:16AM +0200, Javier Martinez Canillas wrote:
>> The SPI core always reports the MODALIAS uevent as "spi:<modalias>"
>> regardless of the mechanism that was used to register the device
>> (i.e: OF or board code) and the table that is used later to match
>> the driver with the device (i.e: SPI id table or OF match table).
>>
>> So drivers needs to export the SPI id table and this be built into
>> the module or udev won't have the necessary information to autoload
>> the needed driver module when the device is added.
>>
>> But this means that OF-only drivers needs to have both OF and SPI id
>> tables that have to be kept in sync and also the dev node compatible
>> manufacturer prefix is stripped when reporting the MODALIAS. Which can
>> lead to issues if two vendors use the same SPI device name for example.
>>
>> To avoid the above, the SPI core behavior may be changed in the future
>> to not require an SPI device table for OF-only drivers and report the
>> OF module alias. So, it's better to also export the OF table even when
>> is unused now to prevent breaking module loading when the core changes.
>>
>> Signed-off-by: Javier Martinez Canillas <javier at osg.samsung.com>
> 
> I appreciate the context for the whole problem here, but this commit
> subject mostly doesn't apply to this driver, and it deson't seem to
> match the problem this is solving. As I see it, the patch description
> for this patch should be more like:
> 
>   "The OF ID table is used for auto-probing the device, but it is not
>   exported to the module device table. That means this driver won't
>   autoload when built as a module.
> 
>   Export the OF ID table to fix that.
> 
>   (insert some reference to the larger issue here)"
> 
> Do you want to rewrite the message, shall I just prepend my
> modifications, or am I off-base?
>

Well, I believe my commit message is more accurate than yours :-)

I mean, right now the OF modalias information is not really used neither
by the SPI core since always MODALIAS=spi:foo is reported nor by user
space since the MODALIAS uevent will never match the OF exported modalias.

So this patch really is a no-op right now and is not fixing anything.
As long as the driver has a MODULE_DEVICE_TABLE(spi,...), things will
work without a MODULE_DEVICE_TABLE(of,...).

However, this patch is needed to avoid breaking module autoloading in
the future once RFC patch 18/18 is applied and the SPI core is changed
to report a MODALIAS=of:N*T*Cfoo,bar for SPI devices registered by OF.

Having said that, I will of course re-spin the patch and write a
commit message that you agree on. So I'll be happy to trim it down if
is providing too much content or is not correct.

I just don't think your suggestion better matches reality than mine.

Best regards,
-- 
Javier Martinez Canillas
Open Source Group
Samsung Research America