[PATCH v2 07/16] mtd/docg3: add OOB layout to mtdinfo

[Robert Jarzmik]

Mike Dunn <mikedunn at newsguy.com> writes:

> On 11/10/2011 12:05 AM, Robert Jarzmik wrote:
>> +static struct nand_ecclayout docg3_oobinfo = {
>> +	.eccbytes = 8,
>> +	.eccpos = {7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14},
>> +	.oobfree = {{0, 7}, {15, 1} },
>> +	.oobavail = 8,
>> +};
>> +

I took a different approach.  I check an internal docg3 register to see if the
page was written. Or I could had have checked the Hamming code, as I don't think
it can be 0xff whatever the pagesize 7 bytes values.

The reason behind is that the Hamming code is Ham(64, 57), ie. Ham(2^6,
2^6-6-1). The means the 6 bits are enough to cover all codewords possibilities,
and 0xff is not one of them.

So unless a bitflip in Hamming code, 0xff in it means blank page. And I think
the ECC engine is even smarter, with the ECCCONF1_PAGE_IS_WRITTEN.

>
> Just FYI, per Ivan's suggestion, I changed this to use the last oob byte as a
> "page programmed" flag for the purpose of detecting bit flips when reading a
> blank page.  Maybe something to keep in mind.  You can have a look at the latest
> G4 driver patch to see exactly how I use it.
I personally think this should be provided by the MTD API. A function
is_page_blank(ofs) could tell if the page was written or not. Now if the
function is NULL, the upper layer (UBIFS, ...) could decide _by itself_ to
assign a free OOB byte to that meaning. But IMHO it's not the drivers duty to
take these decisions to restrict the OOB, let it be done at an upper level.

Cheers.

-- 
Robert