[PATCH] PCI: mediatek-gen3: Fix translation window

[Alexandre Mergnat]

On 11/10/2023 14:26, Jianjun Wang wrote:
> The size of translation table should be a power of 2, using fls() cannot 
> get the proper value when the size is not a power of 2. For example, 
> fls(0x3e00000) - 1 = 25, hence the PCIe translation window size will be 
> set to 0x2000000 instead of the expected size 0x3e00000. Fix translation 
> window by splitting the MMIO space to multiple tables if its size is not 
> a power of 2.

Hi Jianjun,

I've no knowledge in PCIE, so maybe what my suggestion is stupid:

Is it mandatory to fit the translation table size with 0x3e00000 (in 
this example) ?
I'm asking because you can have an issue by reaching the maximum 
translation table number.

Is it possible to just use only one table with the power of 2 size above 
0x3e00000 => 0x4000000 ( fls(0x3e00000) = 26 = 0x4000000). The downside 
of this method is wasting allocation space. AFAIK I already see this 
kind of method for memory protection/allocation in embedded systems, so 
I'm wondering if this method is safer than using multiple table for only 
one size which isn't a power of 2.


-- 
Regards,
Alexandre