[PATCH v8 20/20] KVM: ARM64: Add a new kvm ARM PMU device

[Shannon Zhao]

On 2016/1/7 22:56, Peter Maydell wrote:
>>>> +  Errors:
>>>> >>> +    -ENXIO: Unsupported attribute group
>>>> >>> +    -EBUSY: The PMU overflow interrupt is already set
>>>> >>> +    -ENODEV: Getting the PMU overflow interrupt number while it's not set
>>>> >>> +    -EINVAL: Invalid vcpu_index or PMU overflow interrupt number supplied
>>> >>
>>> >> What happens if you create a PMU but then never set the IRQ number?
>>> >> Is there a default or does the VM refuse to run or something?
>>> >>
>> > If userspace doesn't specify the irq number, the guest will not receive
>> > the PMU interrupt because we check if the irq is initialized when we
>> > inject the interrupt. But guest could still use the vPMU if QEMU
>> > generates a proper DTB or ACPI.
> So is it a valid use case to create a PMU with the interrupt not wired
> up to anything? (If it's never valid it would be nice to diagnose it
> rather than just silently letting the guest run but not work right.)
So how about adding a helper to check if the PMU is completely
initialized and if not, return trap_raz_wi when guest access PMU registers?

Thanks,
-- 
Shannon