imx53 memory detection

[Jason Cobham]

Hi Sascha,

Thanks for the quick reply.

> So you replaced barebox_arm_entry with imx53_barebox_entry, right? What
> memory size do you have and what size gets detected then?

Yes, I used imx53_barebox_entry. I have two boards, 512MB/1G. In
further testing, I found the 512MB board was detected correctly, and
the 1G board was detected at 2G.

...

> As a first step you should remove the /memory node in
> arch/arm/dts/imx53-ccxmx53.dtsi. Since there are different possible
> memory setups for this board it is wrong anyway. Then it would be
> interesting what imx_esdctl_v4_add_mem() detects. I believe it should be
> possible to fix it if it detects the wrong memory size.

For the 1G board, I removed the memory node and looked into
imx_esdctl_v4_add_mem(). I found:
add_mem: cs0 base: 0x70000000 cs0 size: 0x40000000
add_mem: cs1 base: 0xb0000000 cs1 size: 0x40000000

Going further into it, I found in the imx_v4_sdram_size() read the
following from the esdctl registers:
ctlval:0xc4110000, esdmisc:0xc00016d0 which is set from the
appropriate flash-header file.

The ram populated on the 1G board is MT47H128M16 – 128 Meg x 16 (16
Meg x 16 x 8 banks).
Comparing the register setting against the datasheet for the ram chips
looks like there was a mistake in the row setting of the 1G
flash-header. After updating it to what I believe is correct setting:
(ctlval:0xc3110000, esdmisc:0xc00016d0), the memory is now detected
correctly.

Unless you see any Issue with my findings, I'll go with this fix.


Thanks,

Jason